Monday, May 2, 2011

momSMARTS: Failing by Example


My husband and I are blessed with two smart kids. Sometimes it doesn't feel as lucky as it sounds, what with their ability to outmaneuver us regarding bedtime and sugar intake with rhetorical gymnastics that would impress Supreme Court justices, but in general we recognize and are thankful for daughters who don't face  major obstacles in mastering new challenges.

But I worry anyway. With a tween and a newly-hatched teen in the house, and high school not far in the future, I've been brushing up on developmental literature to help negotiate the changing family dynamics (my favorite, both in content and title: How to Hug A Porcupine: Negotiating the Prickly Points of the Tween Years by Julie Ross.)  Some of this literature points to the fact that kids who have not had to struggle academically in elementary and middle school are worse off than their peers when they meet the rigor of high school; having never had to "learn how to learn," they are flummoxed when the material doesn't just sink right in.

Of course whenever you read a book like this - and I'm looking at you, "What To Expect When You're Expecting" lady - you spend a lot of time thinking, "Ooops. I don't do that. Oh god, I do exactly the opposite of that, is that bad? I have totally messed these children up! Crap!" I know it's probably not their raison d'etre, but making you feel like a lousy parent does seem to be a predictable byproduct of any parenting book.

So I was pretty thrilled when I realized that there is one thing I have done right: I've let my kids see me fail.

About five years ago I was working in a corporate job and percolating the idea of leaving it all to write a novel; not the Great American Novel, more like the Great American Subway Read. I had the story, I had the characters, and I had the passion. So, with the financial and moral support of my husband, I sat down and I wrote. For about three years, the kids saw me spend hours writing at my computer, watched me edit early drafts, listened as I belabored plot points with anyone who would listen. They saw me off on research trips, they overheard me read parts aloud to gauge the rhythm and flow, and they celebrated the day the 450 page draft was done.

And they heard my reaction when the book was rejected by a baker's dozen worth of publishing companies, with an exhortation to "keep working on it!" In short, my daughters saw me fail.

But they did not see me give up. Sure, I floundered for awhile, and I was sad. But I wasn't defeated. For now, I have other stories to tell, on my blog and in essays. I have shelved the novel, but I am confident that someday I will figure out how best to tell that story, a story so deeply ingrained that I swear it pulses in my cells.  I tell my kids that writing that unpublished novel was the hardest thing I ever did, and that I'm proud of myself, even if it's not in a bookstore. I tell them the rejections were a good reminder to me that I can do better work.

My hope is that when it's their turn fall short of a goal , they'll think of me, their failure of a mother, and take heart. 

Nancy Davis Kho blogs about the blessings and absurdities of everyday life at Normalarkey. She's a writer, a reader, a bike wife, a mom, and a music fan. And they don't call her Aunt Blabby for nothing.

13 comments:

Ed Keating said...

Great lesson Nancy. Well written. I am sure good things will come from all the work on the book.

Anonymous said...

Nancy - Just like "Pink is the New Black", and "Flat is the New Up", your story reminds us all that in leadership it is Perseverance and Resilance that are the cornerstone of great careers - and lives. And yes - an important part of parenthood. One of the those Knowing Pains we wrote about a few years ago... So for you I coin:

"Surviving and Thriving After Failure is the New Success"

congrats on staying true to your vision and I for one, want to read that #$@% book of yours.
Elizabeth

Nancy Davis Kho said...

I read an interview with Kathryn Stockett, author of "The Help", over the weekend - SIXTY ONE rejections before her book, about to release as a movie too, was picked up. So statistically speaking I'm still in the minor leagues. Now I just need a year, a houseboat with no internet connection, and an unlimited supply of peanut butter and rice cakes. I could totally get it done.

Smarts Magazine said...

I think the most important thing is that they saw you TRY!

Anonymous said...

As a kid, I was so "smart" I did well without trying too hard. As I mature, innate smarts is not the skill that I use to succeed--instead I'm working on accepting failure and rejection because they are an every day occurrence. I succeed when I know in my heart that I've done work that I'm satisfied with, end of story. The only A I'm looking for is in the Effort column. As a parent who's deep in the midst of potty training, I try to reward effort just as loudly, if not louder than, accomplishment. Thank you, Nancy!

Tiffany K. said...

The best stories come from the experience of failure - so we laugh, pick ourselves up again, and teach our kids (and ourselves) a good lesson. Thanks for some great insight!

MisterSmarts said...

Exceptional SMARTS entry, Nancy. Love the message you're sharing here and I hope we get to see more of you on SMARTS soon!

Julie said...

I love this. I've tried a number of things in my life - and with one of the most recent things I've been doing - I learned that failure isn't necessarily bad... but rather a good learning experience. I hope that someday I can pass that along to someone else. :)

Poker Chick said...

I think if your definition of "failure" is finishing a goal you set for yourself (you said you set out to WRITE a novel, which you did), you're doing ok! Effort brings opportunity.

Andrew said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
amy3565 said...

Showing your kids that failure is ok is a real smart thing - although I agree with Poker Chick, you did meet your goal of writing the novel (which I'd love to read if possible). Every person needs to know that failure is OK as long as you gave it your best shot. If you are afraid to fail, then you may inadvertently stop trying things you think you may not succeed in which in turn just holds you back.

Justin said...

I totally agree with letting your kids see you fail, I think it is also good to let your kids fail as well. A huge part of learning to compete, which they will have to do later in life, is learn to loose graciously. Whenever my kid and I compete, I make sure to win at least 1/3 of the time, this way he learns to deal with his feelings of failure. Failure is ok, it makes one stronger.

PeaceLoveGuac said...

Smart mom and lucky kids. What a great lesson to teach them!